State Dept. in Free Fall as Staffers ‘Fear Getting Punished’ for Warning Trump Is Breaking the Law
Current and former lawyers at the U.S. Department of State’s Office of the Legal Adviser (“L”) are expressing unprecedented hesitation to provide candid legal guidance, fearing professional repercussions if their advice conflicts with the Trump administration’s aggressive foreign policy agenda.
Multiple former “L” employees described a culture of self-censorship and staff exodus, raising alarms about the erosion of independent legal counsel in shaping international actions.
The concerns, detailed in a Saturday HuffPost report based on interviews with several ex-officials, center on a “severe and unusual fear of being punished for doing their jobs.” Lawyers reportedly worry that flagging potential violations of domestic or international law could result in being sidelined, demoted, or pushed out entirely.
The atmosphere marks a significant departure from historical norms at “L,” traditionally valued for frank, nonpartisan analysis. “We’ve always had a culture where we speak frankly, challenge things and really push ideas to ensure they’re solidly supported,” one former lawyer said. Now, there’s “an underlying fear of … providing advice that wasn’t well-received and then being cut out of a subject, being further and further removed from the job that you spent your career trying to do.”
‘Drastic’ Actions and Legal Vetting Concerns
The trepidation has been exacerbated by President Trump’s bold international moves, including military strikes on accused drug-smuggling vessels in South American waters—a policy critics argue lacks clear congressional authorization or alignment with international law.
“It’s really difficult to imagine how any State Department lawyer could sign off on these strikes,” said Charlie Trumbull, a former “L” employee. “That leads me to believe that the normal vetting process for vetting these things is not functioning as it did.”
Trumbull highlighted “much more hesitancy to give advice that the political appointees might not want to hear,” suggesting a chilling effect on the office’s core mission: ensuring U.S. actions comply with treaties, statutes, and norms.
The report also notes a “drastic and uncommon loss of staff” since Trump’s second term began, with experienced lawyers departing amid the perceived politicization.
The Office of the Legal Adviser has long served as the State Department’s in-house counsel, providing objective analysis on everything from treaty negotiations to use-of-force decisions. Its independence is seen as essential to avoiding legal missteps that could damage U.S. credibility abroad.
Former officials describe past administrations Republican and Democratic—as valuing pushback from “L,” even when inconvenient. The current environment, they say, prioritizes alignment over rigor.
The reported self-censorship raises concerns about unchecked executive actions. Trump’s strikes on drug boats, framed as counter-narcotics operations, have drawn questions about jurisdiction, proportionality, and adherence to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea.
Without robust legal vetting, critics warn of risks: diplomatic backlash, escalation with regional powers, or domestic challenges under the War Powers Resolution.
Looking At A Pattern of Institutional Strain Here
The revelations fit broader patterns in Trump’s second term: rapid staff turnover, loyalty tests for appointees, and public clashes with career officials perceived as disloyal. Similar concerns have surfaced at the Justice Department over Epstein file handling and at Defense over military policy.
For “L”—a relatively small office of career experts, the staff losses and caution could have lasting effects, depleting institutional knowledge at a time of global volatility.
TOP STORIES
- Trump Sends Ominous Message to Democrats Pushing for Full Release of Epstein Files: ‘Enjoy What May Be Your Last Merry Christmas’
- ‘Evil Ages Like Milk’: Karoline Leavitt Shares ‘Behind-the-Scenes’ Photos After Being Mocked for Her Viral Lip Close-Up
- DOJ Declares Epstein Note Saying Trump Loves ‘Young, Nubile Girls’ Is ‘FAKE’
As Trump’s foreign policy unfolds with characteristic boldness, the quiet fears inside Foggy Bottom highlight a core tension: Can independent legal advice survive in an administration that prizes loyalty above all?
The answer, according to these former officials, will shape not just policy outcomes, but America’s standing as a nation governed by law.
Discover more from STITCH SNITCHES
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.